logo
ISA Grading Advertisement

Fanatics Rebuts Panini's Accusations in Sports Card Market Dispute

* We may earn a commission from purchases made through our affiliate links.

Panini-vs-Fanatics.jpg

In the ever-evolving realm of sports trading cards, a legal skirmish is unfolding. Fanatics, a major player in the arena, faces an antitrust lawsuit from competitor Panini over its intensified endeavors in the sports card sector, especially considering its impending stewardship of the NBA and NFL card sectors.

Staging their defense in a U.S. District Court located in Tampa, Florida, Fanatics is resolute. They believe that Panini’s accusations don’t hold water, particularly in light of antitrust guidelines. A central point of contention raised by Fanatics is Panini's own longstanding practices in the industry.

court-docs-Fanatics.jpg

Drawing attention to a detailed 35-page document, Fanatics paints a vivid picture. For well over a decade, Panini has been at the forefront, acquiring exclusive intellectual property licenses from a myriad of sports leagues and player coalitions. Ironically, Fanatics alleges, this mirrors the actions that Panini now contests. Furthering their point, Fanatics highlights Panini’s ascension in the market, achieved by sidelining competitors through such exclusive deals. If Panini feels overshadowed, Fanatics argues, it's because of a shifting competitive landscape and not due to any wrongdoing on Fanatics' part.

While Panini’s grievance centers on Fanatics overstepping its bounds in the run-up to capturing NBA and NFL licenses, Fanatics deems it a mere byproduct of healthy competition. Their claim? They secured coveted 2021 exclusive licenses with industry giants like the NBA, NFL, and MLB, purely based on competitive merit.

Fanatics goes on to underscore their transparent dealings. They didn't dissuade leagues or players' associations from entertaining Panini's bids. Moreover, there was no behind-the-scenes leveraging to influence these decisions. The reason for such clarifications? According to Fanatics, such events simply didn’t transpire.

Further driving their defense, Fanatics underscores Panini’s failure to showcase tangible evidence of any wrongdoing, as alleged in their recent antitrust lawsuit.

Yet, the plot thickens. Panini, not restricting its legal pursuits to antitrust concerns, also initiated proceedings against Fanatics in Texas. The reason? A sudden exodus of over thirty pivotal Panini staff members, including brand custodians, to Fanatics. To add fuel to the fire, Fanatics also channeled substantial investments into the printing entity responsible for Panini's cards. On top of that, exclusive autograph agreements with three rising stars from the latest NFL Draft have ensured their signed cards are conspicuously absent from Panini's NFL offerings.

Fanatics responds to these series of events, framing them as natural market dynamics. Post securing their licenses, they ventured to enrich the overall collector experience. This included enhancing various facets of the trading card ecosystem, from talent acquisition to fortifying printing capabilities and securing player endorsements.

In the unfolding legal narrative, Fanatics maintains its stance. They refute any allegations of contractual breaches by the employees who transitioned from Panini. Their narrative is clear: employees migrated to Fanatics in pursuit of better compensation. Moreover, they firmly believe that inking exclusive deals with budding stars is both strategic and legitimate, designed to amplify their market footprint and serve their licensing collaborators more effectively. Notably, they emphasize, such moves are in no way a ploy to undercut Panini’s market standing.

Share:

PWCC Auction Advertisement

0 Comments

Related

Sports Card News

Enhanced Insurance Protection Now Available for Canadian Sports Memorabilia Collectors


  • bionic Avatar
  • by bionic
  • April 17, 2024, 3:39 am

Enhanced Insurance Protection Now Available for Canadian Sports Memorabilia Collectors


NFP, in partnership with Berkley Asset Protection, has rolled out a specialized insurance program aimed at providing comprehensive coverage for collectors of sports memorabilia in Canada, filling gaps often left by standard homeowners insurance. NFP, a...

Read More

Historic 1968 Topps Baseball Card Set Sells for Over $1 Million at Auction


  • bionic Avatar
  • by bionic
  • April 15, 2024, 3:35 am

Historic 1968 Topps Baseball Card Set Sells for Over $1 Million at Auction


A meticulously maintained set of 1968 Topps baseball cards, nearly all graded PSA 10, was sold for a total of $1.1 million by Mile High Card Company, reflecting the high value collectors place on pristine vintage sports cards. At a recent auction by Mi...

Read More

Shohei Ohtani's Interpreter Accused of Misusing Star's Funds for Personal Gain


  • bionic Avatar
  • by bionic
  • April 11, 2024, 3:28 am

Shohei Ohtani's Interpreter Accused of Misusing Star's Funds for Personal Gain


Federal charges have been brought against Ippei Mizuhara, interpreter for MLB player Shohei Ohtani, alleging he misappropriated millions from Ohtani’s accounts to cover personal expenses, including purchasing hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of ...

Read More