logo
ISA Grading Advertisement

Knoxville Store Burglarized, $22,000 in Autographed Jerseys Stolen

* We may earn a commission from purchases made through our affiliate links.

Screenshot 2024-06-07 004514.png

In a brazen act of theft, Cody Denning has been arrested and charged with multiple offenses including burglary, theft of property, and vandalism following his break-in at Underdog Collectibles in Knoxville. The Knoxville Police Department reported that Denning smashed the storefront window and made off with 17 valuable autographed jerseys, totaling almost $22,000 in losses for the store.

The burglary unfolded late on May 18 when Denning initially visited the store, appearing to case the jerseys he later stole. Surveillance footage captured him examining and rearranging the jerseys at approximately 8:50 p.m., during which he mentioned to his wife his plans to return for them. His criminal intentions were realized hours later, when he forcibly entered the store by throwing a rock through the window and conducted two separate thefts early in the morning.
Denning's attempts to liquidate some of the stolen goods were recorded when he tried to sell two of the jerseys at a local sports retailer, Pro Image Sports in West Town Mall. Additionally, police noted that surveillance footage from Denning's vehicle showed multiple hats, also reported missing from the store, confirming his involvement in the theft.

Following the incident, Underdog Collectibles reached out to the public via social media for assistance in recovering the stolen jerseys. They urged anyone who might come across the jerseys to contact them for verification through the serial numbers provided, in hopes of apprehending the perpetrator and retrieving the stolen items.

The store assured the public that the physical damage to the store was minimal and that no one was harmed during the break-in. They continue to seek the public's help in locating the stolen merchandise to prevent further thefts and aid in their recovery efforts.


4
Share:

PWCC Auction Advertisement

0 Comments

  • You must be logged in to comment.
Related

Sports Card News

Mysteries at the Well: What’s Coming in Lorcana’s Tenth Set


  • October 24, 2025, 7:42 pm

Mysteries at the Well: What’s Coming in Lorcana’s Tenth Set


Lorcana’s tenth release is nearly here, and the buzz is all about secrets and sleuthing. Whispers in the Well lands as the second set of the current rotation, with Disney and Ravensburger keeping plenty under lock and key. Even so, previews and leaks sketch o…

Read More

Shimmer and Story: A Quick Tour of 2025 Topps Chrome Disney Sapphire


  • October 23, 2025, 7:44 pm

Shimmer and Story: A Quick Tour of 2025 Topps Chrome Disney Sapphire


Topps turned the Disney universe up a notch after locking in the Disney, Marvel, and Pixar license in September 2024. The company has touched these worlds for years in both physical and digital releases, but that deal cleared the path for a full Chrome set an…

Read More

Rookie Patch First: Brooks Barnhizer’s Unexpected Place in Hobby History


  • October 22, 2025, 7:48 pm

Rookie Patch First: Brooks Barnhizer’s Unexpected Place in Hobby History


Brooks Barnhizer isn’t a household name, yet he just made a quiet bit of card history. On Tuesday, October 21, the 23 year old Oklahoma City Thunder guard stepped into the season opener against the Houston Rockets with 2:21 left in the first quarter and becam…

Read More