Thrift Store Miracle: Kentucky Man Scores Rare Baseball Cards and Yogi Berra Autograph for $20
* We may earn a commission from purchases made through our affiliate links.
A Collector’s Dream Come True in the Middle of a Goodwill Aisle
Christopher Kidney wasn’t expecting much when he stopped into his local Goodwill in Flemingsburg, Kentucky. Maybe a vintage jersey, a dusty record, or a forgotten paperback. What he found instead? An armload of rare, autographed baseball memorabilia worth hundreds of dollars—purchased for less than the price of a pizza.
Tucked into the shelves were signed cards from MLB greats like Don Mattingly, CC Sabathia, and Chuck Knoblauch, plus a Super Bowl XLII card signed by Plaxico Burress. But the real showstopper was a baseball signed by the legendary Yogi Berra, a Hall of Fame catcher whose impact on the game—and the culture of baseball—spanned generations.
A Sharp Eye and a Bit of Luck
“I’ve got a good eye for sports memorabilia,” Kidney said in an interview with Newsweek. “When I saw the names on the cards, I knew they weren’t fakes.”
His instincts paid off. The collection has since sold to private buyers for over $500, though Kidney made it clear the real value came from the thrill of the find—and the emotional connection.
Yogi Berra’s Signature Among the Treasures
The Berra ball alone would’ve made the trip worthwhile. Yogi Berra—real name Lawrence Peter Berra—was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1972 and won 10 World Series titles with the Yankees. His signature, already rare in pristine form, is a coveted addition to any collector’s shelf. Finding one unexpectedly in a thrift store bin? Almost unheard of.
From Goodwill to Viral Fame
Kidney shared his discovery with fellow collectors on Reddit, where it quickly blew up. His post, captioned “Incredible, still shaking,” drew over 1,500 upvotes and hundreds of enthusiastic replies.
"You’re the reason I still check the Goodwill display case every time," one commenter wrote.
Another joked, “Somewhere there’s a Goodwill employee regretting not Googling those names.”
Not His First Thrift Store Gem
Even more incredible—this wasn’t Kidney’s only recent success. Just weeks earlier, he uncovered a 1949 book signed by Honus Wagner for $1.59. Yes, that Honus Wagner—the Pittsburgh Pirates legend whose T206 card remains the holy grail of baseball collecting.
Kidney called the find emotional, citing his late grandfather who once worked for several Major League teams: “It felt like he was with me in that moment.”
More Than Just a Lucky Break
For Kidney, this is more than just resale value—it’s about the stories, the history, and sharing the experience with loved ones. “I owe a lot to my wife Ashley and my best friends Brad and Christopher Davisson,” he said. “They’re part of the reason I keep collecting.”
It’s a reminder that the next hobby goldmine could be sitting in a $1 bin at your local thrift. All it takes is a sharp eye, a little luck, and a love for the game.
0 Comments
Discuss on Forums