logo
ISA Grading Advertisement

Two Men Admit to Stealing Over $2 Million in Baseball Cards from Ohio Hotel

* We may earn a commission from purchases made through our affiliate links.

Screenshot 2024-10-04 125610.png

Two men have pleaded guilty in connection with the theft of vintage baseball cards valued at over $2 million from a hotel in Strongsville, Ohio.

Defendants:

  • Jacob Paxton, 27: An employee at the Best Western hotel where the theft occurred. He pleaded guilty to aggravated theft.
  • Jason Bowling, 51: Pleaded guilty to receiving stolen property.
Incident Overview

On April 17, a FedEx delivery containing 54 vintage baseball cards worth approximately $2,123,447 was dropped off at the Best Western hotel. The cards were shipped by Memory Lane Inc. for a sports card conference taking place nearby.

On April 18, a representative from Memory Lane Inc. arrived at the hotel to collect the package but was unable to locate it. Hotel staff and the representative searched for the package, and when it could not be found, the Strongsville Police Department was notified.

Investigation and Recovery

An investigation by Strongsville police revealed that Paxton had allegedly searched through several packages delivered to the hotel. He is accused of taking the baseball cards and transporting them to Bowling's residence in Cleveland.

On May 23, authorities executed a search warrant at Bowling's home. They recovered 52 of the 54 stolen baseball cards.

Missing Cards

Two valuable cards remain unaccounted for:

  • A 1909 Ramly Walter Johnson card.
  • A 1941 Ted Williams card.





Upcoming Sentencing

Both Paxton and Bowling are scheduled to be sentenced on December 16.

Value and Significance of the Stolen Cards

The stolen collection included rare and highly sought-after vintage baseball cards, significantly contributing to their estimated total value of over $2 million.

Authorities' Statement

Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Michael O’Malley commended the collaborative efforts that led to the swift recovery of most of the stolen items. The investigation highlighted the importance of security measures when handling high-value collectibles.

Community Impact

The incident has raised awareness about the security of valuable items during events and conferences. Collectors and vendors are encouraged to take additional precautions to safeguard their property.

Contact Information

Anyone with information about the missing cards is urged to contact the Strongsville Police Department.

Share:

PWCC Auction Advertisement

1 Comments

Related

Sports Card News

PSA Reveals Comic and Magazine Grading Prices Ahead of July Launch


  • bionic Avatar
  • by bionic
  • July 3, 2025, 9:31 pm

PSA Reveals Comic and Magazine Grading Prices Ahead of July Launch


PSA is preparing to enter the comic book and magazine grading market, and collectors now have a clear picture of what submission costs and timelines will look like. The company announced its official pricing tiers and turnaround estimates this week, wit...

Read More

Pokémon Leads the Charge as Grading Submissions Skyrocket in 2025


  • bionic Avatar
  • by bionic
  • June 29, 2025, 9:15 pm

Pokémon Leads the Charge as Grading Submissions Skyrocket in 2025


The trading card landscape continues to shift in 2025, with Pokémon cards dominating grading submissions across the industry. According to the latest data from GemRate, non-sports and TCG cards now account for nearly 60% of all cards graded through the...

Read More

Trading Card Market Hits Record $305 Million in June, Driven by eBay and Grading Surge


  • bionic Avatar
  • by bionic
  • July 1, 2025, 9:10 pm

Trading Card Market Hits Record $305 Million in June, Driven by eBay and Grading Surge


The trading card industry saw a historic surge in June, with collectors spending more than $305 million across eBay, auction houses, and marketplaces—a new single-month record for the hobby. According to Card Ladder, which tracks market data across t...

Read More