logo
ISA Grading Advertisement

NFLPA Terminates Panini's License: Fanatics Gains Ground in Trading Card Battle

* We may earn a commission from purchases made through our affiliate links.

1693561010890.png

Just a fortnight after initiating a federal antitrust lawsuit against its competitor, Fanatics, Panini has received a significant blow to its NFL trading card production. The NFL Players Association (NFLPA) has decided to terminate Panini's license to use player names and likenesses for trading cards prematurely, shifting those rights to Fanatics.

According to reports, the NFLPA informed player agents of this decision, effectively ending Panini's contract ahead of schedule and granting those rights to Fanatics. This surprising development marks a notable change in the trading card landscape, with Fanatics securing a stronger foothold in the market.

It's important to note that Panini had the rights to produce NFL trading cards until the 2026 season when Fanatics was initially set to take over the license. However, the NFLPA's decision has accelerated this transition.

The NFLPA's letter emphasizes that this decision will not impact players who have individual contracts with Panini, urging them to honor their existing agreements.

This development solidifies Fanatics' position as a significant player in the sports trading card industry, as it now holds the rights to produce both baseball and football cards. However, it's worth noting that Fanatics cannot use any team names or logos unless the NFL also terminates its contract with Panini.

This legal battle between Panini and Fanatics has taken a contentious turn. Fanatics claims it had attempted to negotiate the buyout of Panini's remaining years for NFL and NBA licenses, but the deal fell through, prompting Panini to sue Fanatics. In its lawsuit, Panini alleges that Fanatics sought to monopolize the market for professional sports league trading cards, an accusation Fanatics vehemently denies.

Panini's response to the NFLPA's decision expressed its disappointment and disagreement. The company believes that the NFLPA's action, in conjunction with Fanatics, is unwarranted and improper, particularly considering Panini's substantial contributions to the sports trading card category's growth.

As Fanatics has not yet issued a statement regarding this development, the future of Panini and its ability to continue producing NFL football cards remains uncertain. With this significant license loss and its ongoing legal battle, Panini's outlook is uncertain, raising questions about the direction of the sports trading card hobby as Fanatics continues to exert greater influence over card manufacturing.

Panini's antitrust lawsuit against Fanatics alleges anticompetitive conduct by Fanatics to monopolize the trading card markets, a legal battle that could have far-reaching implications for the industry. As both companies vie for dominance in the trading card arena, collectors and enthusiasts are left eagerly watching the outcome of this high-stakes legal contest.

Share:

PWCC Auction Advertisement

2 Comments

Related

Sports Card News

Cooper Flagg Makes Pro Debut in the Hobby with First Topps NOW Card


  • bionic Avatar
  • by bionic
  • June 26, 2025, 8:34 pm

Cooper Flagg Makes Pro Debut in the Hobby with First Topps NOW Card


In a move that felt more inevitable than surprising, Cooper Flagg has been selected first overall in the 2025 NBA Draft. The Dallas Mavericks, who made waves by trading Luka Doncic earlier this season, have officially hit the reset button—and they’v...

Read More

Stephen Curry Gets the Manga Treatment in VeeFriends’ Latest Sticker Drop


  • bionic Avatar
  • by bionic
  • June 27, 2025, 8:27 pm

Stephen Curry Gets the Manga Treatment in VeeFriends’ Latest Sticker Drop


Stephen Curry, one of the most electrifying names in basketball, is stepping into an entirely new kind of spotlight—this time, as a manga-style sticker. In a surprise move that blends pop culture, collectibles, and athlete fandom, Curry has teamed up ...

Read More

The Pokémon Card Craze: Are We In a Bubble?


  • bionic Avatar
  • by bionic
  • June 23, 2025, 8:19 pm

The Pokémon Card Craze: Are We In a Bubble?


Every Friday, it’s the same story across retail stores nationwide—long lines, empty shelves, and a stampede of collectors and flippers hoping to score Pokémon cards before they vanish. The Pokémon Trading Card Game, once a niche nostalgia trip, ha...

Read More